Can I ask a question, has anyone had stage 1 breast cancer but grade 3 her2 positive? If so did you do chemotherapy...
Ask Navis about your situation
This answer is general. Get one about your specific case. No signup, answered right here.
For informational purposes only
This answer was generated by AI grounded in NCCN guidelines and published medical literature. It is not medical advice. Always consult your oncologist or care team before making treatment decisions.
Sources & medical oversight
- Built by OpenCancer’s team of physician-scientists and cancer survivors.
- Last updated October 3, 2026. Informational only — not a substitute for your oncology team.
Question asked:
Can I ask a question, has anyone had stage 1 breast cancer but grade 3 her2 positive? If so did you do chemotherapy then lumpectomy then radiation and then another chemo called kadacly for 14 sessions. What was peoples outcomes and did any of you get to remission only once I finished my radiation I ...
Understanding Your Stage 1, Grade 3, HER2+ Breast Cancer Treatment Plan
I can see you're looking for patient experiences with a specific treatment pathway. While I can't connect you with other patients directly, I can help you understand what the medical evidence says about your situation and what questions to ask your care team about outcomes.
Let me break down what we know about your cancer type and treatment approach:
Your Cancer Type: Stage 1, Grade 3, HER2-Positive
What this means:
According to NCCN Guidelines, your cancer has some important characteristics:
- Stage 1 = Early-stage disease (tumor is relatively small, hasn't spread to lymph nodes or distant sites)
- Grade 3 = High-grade (cells look very abnormal under the microscope and tend to grow faster)
- HER2-positive = Your cancer cells have extra copies of the HER2 protein, which makes them grow faster BUT also makes them responsive to targeted therapy
The combination of early stage with high grade and HER2+ status is actually significant because HER2-targeted therapy is very effective for this subtype. As noted in NCCN Guidelines for Invasive Breast Cancer, HER2+ cancers are treated with targeted therapies that specifically block this protein.
Your Treatment Plan: Breaking It Down
Your treatment sequence appears to be:
- Chemotherapy (before surgery) - called neoadjuvant therapy
- Lumpectomy (surgery)
- Radiation therapy
- Ado-trastuzumab emtansine (Kadcyla) - 14 sessions
Why this sequence makes sense:
According to NCCN Guidelines, for HER2+ breast cancer:
"Chemotherapy with a HER2-targeted therapy is used to treat HER2+ cancer. Trastuzumab and pertuzumab are examples of HER2-targeted therapy."
Your upfront chemotherapy helps shrink the tumor before surgery, which is called preoperative (neoadjuvant) therapy. After surgery, additional HER2-targeted therapy continues to target any remaining cancer cells.
Kadcyla (ado-trastuzumab emtansine) specifically:
- This is an antibody-drug conjugate (ADC) that attaches directly to HER2 on cancer cells
- It delivers chemotherapy directly into HER2+ cancer cells
- NCCN Guidelines note that Kadcyla is used particularly when there is residual disease (cancer remaining) after initial treatment
What the Evidence Shows About Outcomes
Important context: I don't have access to specific patient outcome data or survival statistics in my knowledge base, but here's what the medical literature supports:
For HER2+ breast cancer with your treatment approach:
According to NCCN Guidelines for Invasive Breast Cancer, the standard approach for HER2+ disease includes:
- Chemotherapy combined with HER2-targeted therapy
- Continuation of HER2-targeted therapy for up to 1 year total
- Radiation therapy when appropriate (as in your plan)
The guidelines emphasize that HER2-targeted therapy has significantly improved outcomes for patients with HER2+ breast cancer compared to chemotherapy alone.
Questions to Ask Your Oncology Team About YOUR Specific Outcomes
Since you're asking about remission and what to expect, here are targeted questions:
-
"Based on my specific pathology results and response to the initial chemotherapy, what is my risk of recurrence?" (This helps you understand your individual prognosis)
-
"What does 'remission' mean in my case, and what will we be monitoring for after I complete Kadcyla?" (Different doctors use this term differently)
-
"After I finish the 14 sessions of Kadcyla, what is my follow-up plan?" (This includes imaging, blood work, and how often you'll be seen)
-
"Are there any biomarker tests (like Oncotype DX or similar) that could help predict my individual response to this treatment?" (Some patients find this helpful for understanding their specific risk)
-
"What symptoms should I report immediately, and what's the difference between expected side effects and something that needs urgent attention?"
-
"Will I need any additional endocrine therapy (hormone therapy) after HER2-targeted therapy is complete?" (This depends on whether your cancer is also hormone receptor-positive)
Finding Patient Support & Stories
While I can't connect you with specific patients, here are evidence-based resources:
- American Cancer Society (cancer.org) - has patient stories and support communities
- Breastcancer.org - extensive patient forums organized by cancer type
- NCCN Patient Guides (nccn.org/patientguidelines) - includes real patient perspectives
- Your hospital's patient navigator or social worker - can often connect you with support groups specific to HER2+ breast cancer
Key Takeaway
Your treatment plan aligns with NCCN Guidelines for HER2-positive breast cancer, which emphasizes the combination of chemotherapy, surgery, radiation, and extended HER2-targeted therapy. The fact that you're receiving this comprehensive approach reflects current best practices for your cancer subtype.
The most important conversation is with your medical oncologist about:
- How your tumor responded to the initial chemotherapy
- Your individual risk factors
- What remission and long-term monitoring will look like for YOU specifically
This information is for educational purposes only. Always consult your healthcare team for personalized medical advice and decisions.
Ask Navis about your case
That answer is general. Ask about your specific situation. No signup, answered right here.
Facing this with someone you love?
Keep the whole picture in one private place: records, a plain-language summary of where things stand, questions, and the people helping. Navis keeps it up to date so no one has to re-explain the story. Free, and only the people you invite can ever see it.
Start a care circle →Related Services
Services that may help with treatment for cancer patients
Have your records handy? Upload them for a deeper, personalized analysis →
Related Questions
NED Hello, Just wondering if anyone here who took or is taking tagrisso was ever NED after progression? Waiting for...
I can hear the anxiety in your message—waiting for scan results is genuinely stressful. Let me provide some educational context that might help while
My mom just had to shave her head (breast cancer - chemo and radiation). She is looking for lightweight head...
I appreciate you looking out for your mom during this challenging time! While head coverings aren't really my area of expertise I focus on helping und
For all the ladies who have had a mastectomy…did you go straight to implant or have DEIP reconstructive surgery?...
I appreciate you reaching out, and I can tell this is an important decision you're considering! 💕 However, I should be transparent about what I am:
Over the past year I’ve developed drenching night sweats and enlarged lymph nodes in my neck and collarbone that can...
I'm sorry you're going through this uncertainty. Let me help you understand what's happening and what to expect. Your symptoms and findings: - Night
So home health agency was recommended to a loved one after a 14 day stay in the hospital,,, we don’t understand home...
I can hear the frustration and concern in your message. It sounds like there was a confusing interaction with the home health agency, and you're tryin
Has anyone dealt with someone who just doesnt sleep. We've been doing 5 days a week radiation and twice weekly chemo...
I'm hearing real exhaustion and concern in your message—both for your loved one and likely for you as a caregiver. Sleep disruption during cancer trea
Been in the hospital since Saturday. His symptoms of chemo neurotoxicity are getting worse. He was put on a feeding...
I can hear how frightened you are, and that's completely understandable. Watching your husband go through this is incredibly hard. Let me address what
Anyone currently taking oral chemo (specifically Xeloda) experiencing mouth sores/PAIN/extremely raw dry lips and...
Yes, what you're describing is a very common side effect of Xeloda capecitabine, and many patients experience exactly what you're reporting. This is c